Allyn Fives
Search for other papers by Allyn Fives in
Current site
Google Scholar
in Judith Shklar and the liberalism of fear
Abstract only
Log-in for full text

What do the victims of tyranny owe each other? In this chapter, I examine whether they can be condemned for betraying their friends, and I do so through a novel interpretation of Judith Shklar’s political thought. Shklar is a widely acknowledged and significant influence on non-ideal theory, including political realism. However, there is also a previously unnoticed transformation between her early and mature work, for, although she remains a sceptic, her approach to moral conflict changes from value pluralism to value monism. In addition, it is only in her mature work, as a monist, that she believes tyranny cancels obligations of justice. I argue here that Shklar’s monism fails, and this in turn has important implications for non-ideal theory. While non-ideal theorists have focused on developing a sceptical critique of ideal theory, this interpretation of Shklar’s work illustrates that greater awareness is needed of the pitfalls of monist strands of scepticism

  • Collapse
  • Expand


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 168 33 3
Full Text Views 1 1 0
PDF Downloads 2 2 0